Category Archives: Indigenous Religion and Philosophy

Skywoman

 

Robin Wall Kimmerer began her book Braiding Sweetgrass with a Indigenous creation myth–the story of Skywoman. Skywoman fell to the earth from the sky. Kimmerer elegantly describes that fall this way:

 

“She fell like a maple seed pirouetting on an autumn breeze. A column of light streamed from a hole in the Skyworld, marking  her path where only darkness had been before. It took her a long time to fall. In fear or maybe hope, she clutched a bundle tightly in her hand.”

 

Of course, as Skywoman fell toward the earth it appeared she would be crushed by the fall for she fell from a great distance in the sky. Her hair billowed as she spiraled toward the earth.  Fortunately, geese saw her plight and rose to the sky to help her break her fall. They flew beneath Skywoman to break her fall and as they did so, they were able to gently carry her downward but it still appeared that Skywoman would die since she could not swim in the water below. As a result, a turtle offered its back as a place for Skywoman to rest.

 

But Skywoman needed more. She needed earth and there was none, until all the animals tried to dive to the bottom of the water. None could dive enough until muskrat offered to try. Muskrat dove extremely deep. In fact, muskrat dove so deep that it died coming up holding onto the precious earth which the other animals placed on Turtle’s back for Skywoman to use. That earth became the whole planet earth.

 

From that platform Skywoman flourished and danced in gratitude to the fellow creatures that had saved her. Together they saved Skywoman and together they all thrived as a family from what Kimmerer called the “alchemy of all animal gifts coupled with her deep gratitude. Together they formed what we know today as Turtle Island, our home.” The key is the word “together.”  Skywoman did not fight with nature. She worked with nature with gratitude and respect. And that made all the difference.  Skywoman had not come empty-handed either she had grabbed a bundle of fruits and seeds of all kind of plants which she scattered on to the new world of Turtle Island. These seeds provided wild grasses, flowers, trees, and medicines that would enable her to live with all the creatures who came to join her.

 

That old attitude is the new attitude to nature that we need. It starts with a new concept of what Heidegger called “being-in-the-world.” A new attitude can make all the difference in the world.

 

Heidegger, a very difficult German philosopher, who led a very imperfect life, did have some good ideas. One of them was that we—homo sapiens—were not separate and apart from nature as so many European thinkers believed. They were, Heidegger said, part of the world, not separate and apart from the world. We are being-in-the world.  That is a very profound concept. And it was a concept that was not foreign to indigenous people. In fact, they knew it deeply. It guided their relationship to nature. And that attitude has made all the difference in the world.

 

Braiding Sweetgrass by Robin Wall Kimmerer

Robin Wall Kimmerer is a mother, scientist, professor, and member of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation.  She has written a wonderful book, called Braiding Sweetgrass. She is a botanist and combines that profession with indigenous traditional knowledge she has learned from elders.  She respects both branches of knowledge. We should too.

What is really special about her and her book is that she has written it with the benefit of western scientific knowledge as well as indigenous knowledge. When the two work together the results can be magnificent. Readers of her book will benefit from this dual knowledge.

In the book Kimmerer tells of a question she asked of her College Ecology students: what they could tell her about positive interactions between humans and the earth?   Almost all of them could not think of any. She tried to explain that to herself and said it must be because they had seen so many negative interactions like brownfields, factory farms, suburban sprawl and a host of others. It was easy to think of negative interactions between humans and nature, but not good ones.  Kimmerer described this as follows: “As the landscape becomes impoverished, so too does the scope of their vision.”

This reminded me of what Anthony Hall said in a magnificent book, The American Empire and the Fourth World where he showed there was direct line from ecocide (destruction of the earth) to genocide (destruction of first nations). Europeans, when they arrived in the New World, were quick to found their domination over not just Indigenous peoples, but nature itself.  Everything was considered available to them  for conquest. The Westerners rejected the ecological egalitarianism of the indigenous people they encountered who had an entirely different attitude to nature. They saw humans as part of the natural world

The people of the western world had a creation myth that told a story of Adam and Even who would have dominion over all the creatures of the earth.  That dominion has proved a mixed blessing at best, as we look at a world of brownfields, pollution, and climate change.

Robin Wall Kimmerer asked how could we begin to find a path forward in this toxic relationship between nature and humans if we cannot even imagine what that path might look like. Does that mean the case is utterly hopeless? I would suggest it is impossible unless we conceive of a new attitude to nature. Nothing less will do. We need an attitude to nature similar to that of Indigenous people.

Separation from Nature

 

We currently are facing what I call a cascading number of international crises: interminable wars, artificial intelligence which we have created and now at times seems to be threatening us with extinction or enslavement, a loss of spirituality, impoverished relationships with other humans, and a collapsing natural world that seems often to be our enemy rather than our home, and many others. I think a lot of these problems are linked and in fact are affected and amplified by each other. To some extent I believe that these problems have a common source—namely, a wrong-headed attitude to nature that stems from our faulty assumption that we are separate and apart from nature, but also superior to it and can do with it whatever we choose.

 

It is also my belief that this attitude is a long-standing one shared by most—but not all—people and particularly by us in the western world.  This attitude is leading us to serious trouble as clearly demonstrated by these cascading crises. I also think there is a better way based on a more healthy relationship to the natural world and it has been demonstrated by many –but not all—indigenous people.  I do not believe that indigenous people are the same and do not believe that there is an iron law that provides indigenous people are good and white people are bad. We are all mixed. None of us are pure. No tribe has a monopoly on wisdom. Neither does any religion.

 

Yet I also believe there is a lot wisdom that we can all benefit from that has been learned by indigenous people around the world. Us westerners haver too often been arrogant, thinking that we know best and have nothing to learn from others. It is exactly this attitude that is leading us to our doom. We can do better. We must do better.

 

One of those persons from whom I believe we have a lot to learn is an indigenous person called Robin Wall Winterer. She has written some very interesting books. One of them is called Braiding Sweetgrass.  Elizabeth Gilbert called the book “a hymn of love to the world.” The subtitle of the book is “Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge, and the Teachings of Plants.” I want to talk about that book and others. I hope you will travel with me on this meandering journey.

Changing How We do Forestry

 

Suzanne Simard, author of Finding the Mother Tree, also hoped that Canadians in the forest system would change their forestry practices. Sadly, the evidence is not compelling that this has happened. In fact, the evidence points in the other direction. She had hoped that her research would change their practices.

 

In her 2014 Ted Talk Simard showed an aerial photograph of forests within 100 km. of the forest she studied and sadly it showed many large pockets of clear-cut forests. It is far from pristine. In fact, according to the 2014 report of the  World Resources Institute Canada in the past decade has had the highest forest disturbance rate of any country worldwide. This might have surprised many who might have thought that this dubious distinction might have gone to Brazil or Indonesia or Russia. In Canada the rate of forest disturbance is 3.6 percent per year. According to Simard that is 4 times the sustainable rate.

 

Added to that, massive disturbance at this scale is known to affect many other aspects of forest and neighboring ecosystems.  Such disturbances can seriously and adversely affect hydrological cycles, degrade wildlife habitat, and emit greenhouse gases back into the atmosphere. All of this in turn creates a vicious circle of forestry abuse. This leads directly to more disturbance and more tree diebacks.

 

As if that is not bad enough, according to Simard modern North American foresters, when they replant forests they do a very poor job, because often they only plant a couple of species and also weed out what they perceive to be less valuable species such as aspens and birches. According to Simard,

 

These simplified forests lack complexity, and they’re really vulnerable to infections and bugs. And as climate changes, this is creating a perfect storm for extreme events, like the massive mountain pine beetle outbreak that just swept across North America, or that megafire in the last couple months in Alberta.

 

Nature loves diversity; it abhors species poor systems, even if foresters like them.  They like them because they are easier to harvest and easier to replant. We always have to remember that nature bats last. We should be mimicking nature.  That is called biomimicry. We should not be weakening our forests. We should be working hard to strengthening them so that they can deal with future challenges such rapidly approaching climate change. Complex systems like forests have an amazing power to self-heal. But again, they are not omnipotent and never will be even with our help.

 

Simard’s experiments showed that instead of clear-cutting, patch-cutting and retention of hub trees and regeneration to a diversity of species and genes and genotypes could create strong mycorrhizal networks that would help forests recover quickly. There is hope if we learn to act smarter.

 

Simard proposed what she called four simple solutions.  First, we all need to get out in the forest and connect with them and really look at them. We cannot assume they are exactly like other forests where traditional methods might have worked. Each forest is different. We have to get actively involved in our own forests. We have to avoid the traditional one-size-fits-all approach. Good forestry stewardship absolutely requires deep knowledge of local conditions.

 

Secondly, we must save our old-growth forests. These “old growth forests are the repositories of genes and mother trees and mycorrhizal networks”. That means we can’t strip them naked. We have to cut less. Loggers won’t like this but it is absolutely essential. We can cut, but we must cut less.

 

Thirdly, when we do cut, “we need to save the legacies, the mother trees and networks, and the wood, the genes, so they can pass their wisdom onto the next generation of trees so they can withstand the future stresses coming down the road. We need to be conservationists.”  We have to think and act like a forest. We have to mimic nature better—much better—than we have done in the past.

 

Finally, “we must regenerate our forests with a diversity of species and genotypes and structures by planting and allowing natural regeneration. We have to give Mother Nature the tools she needs to use her intelligence to self-heal. And we need to remember that forests aren’t just a bunch of trees competing with each other, they’re super-cooperators.”

 

Simard said she hoped she had changed the way we think about forests. I know she changed my way of thinking about forests. I wish I was more important.

 

I know a lot people including a lot of scientists, perhaps even a substantial majority will be sceptical of this new science. That is as it should be. Science should always question new ideas. But they should also question old ideas! Old ideas should not get a pass. Let the evidence speak.

 

I also wonder if indigenous people would consider this such a radical idea. They often speak of trees, plants, animals, and even rocks, as their kin.

 

Mothers of the Forest

 

When Suzanne Simard was a very young forester she learned from experience that the way foresters were reforesting forests was not working very well.

 

She noticed that after cutting most trees in a swath of trees they replanted selected trees. They did not want to plant trees that they thought might compete with the trees that were “useful.” They also did not leave many tries behind. It was basically a clear cut. When she questioned this approach, the senior forester she worked with asked, “are you an environmentalist?”

 

She had grown up with loggers but they usually did not cut everything. It did not seem right. In time she learned that it wasn’t smart either.

 

She noticed it first as a young forested and the knowledge was later reinforced when she studied the science of forests.  The underground connection between species in the forest consisting of underground mycorrhizal networks. These are networks that connect fungi under the ground to the roots of trees also under the ground. These allowed nutrients and water to be transported between species under the ground invisible except to scientists. The fungus delivers nutrients from old trees to seedlings. Cutting this link was devastating for forest renewal. The old trees could afford to do this because they had plenty to give.

 

As Simard found, “young trees got their start in in the shadow of old trees by linking into their vast mycelium [part of the fungal network under the ground] and receiving substances in return until they could build enough needles and roots to make it on their own…The seedlings in this forest were regenerating in this network of old trees.”

 

This was no accident and it explained why seedlings did best when they were not cut-off from the mature trees that were not just competing with them. They were actually helping the younger trees. As Simard said,

 

“A below ground network could explain why seedlings could survive for years, even decades in the shadows. Those old growth forests were able to self-regenerate because the parents helped the young get on their own two feet. Eventually the young ones would take over the tree line and reach out to others requiring a boost.”

 

I know to many this may sound fantastical.  If you think that you won’t be alone. I am not sure how valid her science is, but she has received a lot attention. And she has credentials.  To me what is most important about her work is that it announces a new attitude to nature, which I firmly believe is badly needed. I have even given a name to this philosophy. I call it affinity. Miriam Webster’s Dictionary defines affinity as sympathy marked by a community of interest. The dictionary uses the example of “she felt an affinity to him because of their common musical interest.”  I would say, a community of interest, like a forest. Like kinship.

 

The Mother Tree Project

 

In 2015 Suzanne Simard began to apply her scientific research findings to the practice of forestry.  She wanted to know if her theories will work in practice. She wanted to reverse the current forestry practice of “free to grow” that was based on the assumption Simard believes is wrong, namely that the best way to regenerate a forest is to keep out the competitors and make the desired trees “free to grow.” She wants foresters to acknowledge that the system they used for decades is not the best. There is a better way.

 

The better way she proposes she calls the Mother Tree Project. It recognizes that trees thrives best when they are connected to the other organisms in the ecosystem, not when they are isolated.  As she said, “the guiding principle of retaining Mother Trees and remaining connections within forests to keep them regenerative, especially as the climate changes.”

 

Simard recognizes that this cooperative and communitarian approach will be needed as forest are subjected to increasing pressures and stresses such a climate change, drought, insect infestation and the like. Simard is confident “Free to Grow” will not work as well as her approach. It has the added benefit of expanding biodiversity.

 

The Project consists of 9 experimental forests located across a “climate rainbow” in British Columbia, for hot and dry forests in the southeast corner to cold and wet stands in the north central interior of the province. Her team of researchers is examining how the structures and functions of the forests and the webs of relationships that play out in them in the real environment will work with the new practices and procedures she endorses. She is confident substantial improvements in forest regeneration will be the result.

 

Then she wants to establish what she calls “an emergent philosophy: complex science.” This new science will be

 

Based on embracing collaboration in addition to competition—indeed, working with all of the multifarious interactions that the forest—complexity science can transform forest practices into what is adaptive and holistic and away from what has been overly authoritarian and simplistic.

 

We can change our ways. We can do better. Our disconnectedness has been the problem. That is where we must make the fundamental changes.  What I have been called a “new attitude to nature.” This disconnectedness is not just causing problems in the forest. It causes problems everywhere. It drives our despair. It defines our alienation. We have to understand the amazing qualities of nature. As she said, it is causing huge problems with our relationship to plants in particular. Like me she is a plant guy. Instead,

 

 “by understanding their sentient qualities, our empathy and love for trees, plants and forests, will naturally deepen and find innovative solutions. Turning to the intelligence of nature itself is the key.”

 

That is the way to discover the wisdom of the forest and that is the way to learn that wisdom.

 

Transformative Thinking

 

 

These two  principles that Suzanne Simard explained she got from the Secwepemc and Salish people are fundamentally the same as similar principles of various North American indigenous groups.   Simard endorses them (as do I).  As Simard opined:

 

“I believe this kind of transformative thinking is what will save us. It is a philosophy of treating the world’s creatures, its gifts, as of equal  importance to us. This begins by recognizing that the trees and plants have agency. They perceive, relate, and communicate: they exercise various behaviors. They cooperate, make decisions, and remember—qualities we normally ascribe to sentience, wisdom, intelligence. By noting how trees, animals, and even fungi—any and all non-human species—have this agency, we can acknowledge that they deserve as much regard as we according ourselves.  We can continue pushing our earth out of balance, with greenhouse gases accelerating each year, or we can regain balance by acknowledging that if we harm, one species, one forest one lake, this ripples through the entire complex web. Mistreatment of one species is mistreatment of all.”

 

It is fascinating and vitally important to realize that these indigenous principles are exactly what Simard’s scientific research leads her to. Simard believes that her  scientific research proves the truth of traditional knowledge. As she said, “the rest of the planet has been waiting patiently for us to figure that out.”

As Simard said,

“Making this transformation requires that humans reconnect with nature—the forests, the prairie, the oceans—instead of treating everything and everyone as objects for exploitation. It means expanding our modern ways, our epistemology, and scientific methodologies, so that they complement, build on, and align with Aboriginal roots. Mowing down the forests and harvesting the waters to fulfill our wildest dreams of material wealth just because we can has caught up with us.”

 

If Simard is right, and she has significant scientific research that points in this direction, it is truly transformative. It would be part of a new attitude to nature. If adopted, it could change the world. Sometimes we need a revolution in our thinking.

Tree People

 

Suzanne Simard understands the importance of logging in British Columbia. She comes from a long line of loggers. Her scientific knowledge has revealed to her that current practices of loggers and their forestry facilitators and their conventional approaches that ignore the importance of connections in the forests between members of the forest communities is not the best.  Hopefully, Simard with her scientific knowledge of forestry and trees, together with the local indigenous people, and their traditional knowledge, that is coming closer together, can teach the British Columbian officials that there is a better way. It is an ancient way practiced by indigenous people in the area for many generations.  It is based on a different attitude to nature that recognizes the importance of the connections in the rainforest between the myriad organisms that live there.

 

Simard’s logging ancestors understood how important logging was to the people who lived there, but they must learn to understand that trees are more than a resource to be exploited. Logging can be a renewable resource, but it requires a respectful attitude to the creatures that occupy the forest ecosystems. Simply seeing forests as a resource is not good enough.

 

Simard learned from an indigenous person named Subiyay who talked of

 

“the trees as people.  Not only with a sort of intelligence—akin to us humans—or even spiritual quality perhaps not unlike ours. Not merely as equivalent to people, with the same bearings.

 

They are people.

The tree people.

           

I don’t presume to grasp Aboriginal knowledge fully. It comes from a way of knowing the earth—an epistemology—different from that of my own culture. It speaks of being attuned to the blooming of the bitterroot, the running of the salmon, the cycles of the moon. Of knowing that we are tied to the land—the trees and animals and soil and water—and to one another, and that we have a responsibility to care for these connections and resources, ensuring sustainability of these ecosystems for future generations and to honor those who came before. Of treading lightly, taking only what gifts we need, and giving back. Of showing humility toward and tolerance for all we are connected too in this circle of life. But what my years in the forestry profession have also shown me is that too many decision-makers dismiss this way of viewing nature and rely only on select parts of science. The impact has become too devastating to ignore. We can compare the condition of the land where it has been torn apart, each resource treated in isolation from the rest, to where it has been cared for according to the Secwepemc principal of k’wseltktnews (translated as “we are all related” or the Salish concept of neca?mat ct (“we are one”).”

 

It was very interesting to me that the scientific knowledge Simard had acquired and the knowledge gained by Indigenous people of the forest through living there for millennia had come to such amazingly similar conclusions—namely that we are all connected.