Category Archives: Extremism

Being a Better Neighbour

 

Will Braun asked members of our group what they wanted to learn about polarization from this course. There were some interesting answers. One person said she wanted to learn to be a better neighbour. Wow, I thought. I need that too. I really need that. Isn’t that what. Jesus recommended as well? Another said, polarization was real and all around us and he wanted to learn how to live in polarized world. Another good point. One woman asked, “how do I live my pacifism in such a situation?” Good questions.  I thought.

 

Will Braun said he wanted us to get beyond the common attitude when discussing issues with those we disagree with, where we gnash our teeth and ask ourselves if we are polite, and asking out loud if we are not, ‘why are those people so stupid?’ Looking down on the others is rarely a good attitude to take if you want to influence others. Just ask Hillary Clinton! She found out that others don’t like a superior attitude.  I know I have to guard against such an attitude. Arrogance is often a cheap and shallow way out of legitimate discussion.

 

Braun said that there are those from both sides that try to impose rules about what we can and cannot discuss with the other side. Those rules are not helpful. “I want to transgress those rules,” said Braun. “Good people who want to discuss things should be able to do that without being batted around,” said Braun. Such rules make people afraid to discuss what needs to be discussed. He also said he was finding the rules that seem to suppress his ability to discuss things are becoming increasingly untenable.

 

I remember our last year in Arizona when we were at a late night party and were among the last 3 couples to leave. There were 2 couples and 1 American couple. The American couple lived close to us as did all of the people at the party. They were all our neighbours. I had though the American couple were staunch Trumpsters. Yet one of us asked them, in the dark of night, after all their friends were gone, most of whom were clearly staunch Trump supporters, “Do you guys like Donald Trump.” The response to the question was breathtaking in its suddenness and surprise.  The woman shouted out, “Fuck No.”  Sorry for using the bad word but it is what she said.  All her friends were Trump supporters. She and her husband were life-long Republicans, but secretly they both hated Trump and everything he stood for.

 

If we had followed the implicit rules about not talking politics with our American friends, as we usually did, we would never have learned that about them and how they had to stickhandle around holding these views secretly. I wondered how many others felt the same way?  We left back for Canada a couple of days later so I could not find out. That’ sad. And it comes from following the rules of decorum. If you are a good neighbour you must be able to discuss issues openly with or you will not benefit from their real views.  And you don’t get to exercise your right of free speech that way either. And usually you don’t find the truth without seeking the truth.

 

Farmers are My Kind of People

 

I know when I moved back to Steinbach after 7 years studying at university in the big smoke, I was apprehensive. These people here did not feel like my kind of people. But guess what? They are my kind of people. I still disagree with them about many things. In some areas, like politics, I usually disagree with them, but they are still my kind of people.

 

The best example of this I can come up with is farmers. I grew up in a small rural town but I only knew one farm family. I loved going there to play on the farm. I thought cows were pretty cool. And Hay piles. I was blown away.

 

Later, after living here in Steinbach as a practicing lawyer, for some years I came to realize that I really liked farmers. They truly were the salt of the earth. We might disagree about politics or religion or social issues, but I really liked them. They were in many respects—in the most important respects—my kind of people. And I had a lot to learn from them, and perhaps, just perhaps they could learn a small tidbit or two from me. By the time I realized this I realized I was in the right place.

 

There was one incident that really solidified this view point for me. It was during the so-called ‘flood of the century” in Manitoba. Many homes were flooded. Some of the owners needed help flood proofing their homes. It was thanks to my son Patrick that I realized I should not remain a bystander. He told me, “Dad we should help.” I realized he was absolutely right we should help and he researched the issue and found a place, a farm where we could help them sand bag their property in the hopes of keeping back the river. He found a farm near Niverville where I worked one day a week and we went out sand bagging and felt good about our little effort.

 

The next day I talked to a client of mine from Niverville. He was a farmer who always lived and worked his farm in the flood plain. He had the right equipment for building dykes from his farm. It was a big farm. He was a very successful farmer and he made his equipment available for his neighbours to use and they worked together on their farms to strengthen their dykes.  I asked him at the end of the day, “What about your farm?”  He answered “I will get to my farm, but these places are more urgent. We must do them first. I said “OK you know what you are doing.” But he didn’t. A couple of days later his farm yard and his farm buildings flooded, but thankfully not his house which was on higher ground and was spared. But he suffered significant losses that he could have avoided by working on protecting his own house first instead of helping his neighbours.

 

This farmer was a mensch. He was the salt of the earth. I wondered if other professionals would have done what he did? I wondered if I would have done what he did? Farmers just seem to do it. Not all of them, but many of them. Farmers are my kind of people.

 

Will Braun my instructor on an upside-down view of polarization at Canadian Mennonite University  also lived in a Bible Belt farming community, like me. He too moved back to his home community in the country in the Bible belt where people are very conservative. As he said about himself, “It’s weird how over time in a new environment, you see things differently. When people around you see things differently you can’t dismiss them. They are good people, even though sometimes you want to dismiss them.”  You should never dismiss people.  That does not mean you always have to agree with them. But recognize that like you they are travelling through life doing the best they can and making mistakes like us. Braun said it has made him be open to broader views. This made him better able to avoid taking too extreme views. They were his kind of people.

 

I hope that living with farmers also expanded my horizons. I fear that too often I have failed to learn from my neighbours. It’s hard to measure up to them.

 

Viewpoint diversity is as good as biodiversity

 

If we really want to find the truth, we need viewpoint diversity. It is as important as biodiversity and basically for the same reason. Cross fertilization breeds strength. As John Stuart Mill, the great philosopher of liberalism, said,

 

“He who knows only one side of the case knows little of that.  His reasons may be good and no one may have been able to refute the reasons on the opposite side, if he does not so much as know what they are, he has no good ground for preferring either opinion.”

 

Such an attitude automatically respects that others may have some truth. We may have something to learn from others. As a result, such an attitude automatically leads us away from extremism.  We then can’t just shout hooray for our side.

Mill makes the point that if you have no viewpoint diversity and listen only to one side, and as a result your ideas are not exposed to challenge, you get stupid! You get intellectually lazy and you just believe dogmatically and then, if you are pushed to explain your viewpoint or defend it, you can’t.

Mill says you should listen to the other side because you might be wrong and because the other side might be right. If you are wrong and you listen to another viewpoint your error might be exposed and then you might avoid making a mistake. That is good!  Similarly, if you are right and yet you listen to another opinion you learn how to defend your opinion and strengthen it. Your opinion will be more solid, more defendable. That is good too! Such humility is also the basis of syncretism and pluralisms, two of my favourite things.

 

Will Braun is a person who enjoys talking with the other side, because he is curious about them, but also because he realizes he might actually learn something from them that he did not know before.

 

Braun, like me, lives in a very conservative area of Manitoba.  When Justin Trudeau was first elected, he said we must remember, “Conservatives are not our enemies; conservatives are our neighbours.” In nearly every debate of substance we must remember, the other side is not our enemies, they are fellow travelers. In Steinbach it is literally true. The conservatives are my neighbours not my enemies. Sometimes I forget that. When I do forget, I am wrong. My bad. Maybe Trudeau forgot that later too. It is easy to forget these wise words. We all do it.

 

Remembering we might be wrong can temper the extremes. That is another good reason to have doubts. Doubts are good.

 

 

Warriors for Christ

 

In my last post I pointed out how Will Braun, our instructor in the CMU class Christiane and I took, in my mind, exemplified some of the best of Mennonites who claimed to be “Die Stillen im Lande” and how it could be used to dissolve extremism.  He was gentle in his thinking and his opinion making.

 

I should point out however how much this attitude is missing from so much current theology particularly from the Evangelical Right.  They don’t want a gentle leader they want a “warrior for Christ” and believe sincerely that they have found one in the person of Donald J. Trump.

 

Many modern evangelical Christians would not be impressed by Will Braun.  They would see him as a Caspar Milquetoast figure. That’s not what they want. They want an extremist. They want a fighter. That’s why they love Donald Trump.

 

Robert Jeffress the pastor of the First Baptist Church of Dallas, and a big fan of Donald Trump, spoke for many Christian Evangelicals in an interview he gave to NPR in 2016. This is what he said about why he defended Trump  Christians would support: “I don’t want some meek and mild leader or somebody who’s going to turn the other cheek. I’ve said I want the meanest, toughest SOB I can find to protect this nation. And so that’s why Trump’s tone doesn’t bother me.”  That does not exactly sound like he wants Jesus

 

As Peter Wehner said in an article in The Atlantic, Jeffress is

 

“one of Donald Trump’s most fawning supporters. By his own account, one reason for his loyalty is that Trump embodies an ethic—cruel, vengeful, and mendacious—that Jeffress and many millions of evangelicals and fundamentalists not only tolerate but welcome.

 

3 years later Jeffress unapologetically said, referring to Trump,  evangelicals “don’t want to see this warrior removed from his place of leadership in our country.”

 

After Trump in 2026 posted an incredible, even by his standards, post in which he railed against the leaders of Iran basically saying in message laced with expletives, he would bomb them into the stone age on Easter Day. Jeffress faithfully continued to support his warrior Christian with these words, “If President Trump were a third-grade Sunday school teacher in our church, that might be a problem, but he’s not a third-grade Sunday school teacher,” he said. “He’s the president of the United States, and presidents sometimes have salty language.”

 

By now it is obvious that nothing Trump can do will result in the Christian Evangelicals giving up on him. They have true religious devotion for him.  He is the leader they want. In fact, Wehner summed up their support this way: “The more merciless, lawless and foulmouthed Trump became, the more his support among conservative evangelicals grew.”

 

That is extreme devotion indeed. I doubt that they give more faithful support to Jesus Christ.

 

Imagine that extremist Christians.

The Gentle Path

 

Will Braun our course leader in the course we took at Canadian Mennonite University  always slid towards the gentle. That, largely, is what I liked so much about the talks he facilitated largely without preaching.  He did it with gentleness. He reminded me of what I know about Vaclav Havel and his velvet revolution.

He also reminded me of Mennonites. In fact, I thought he exemplified the best of the Mennonite perennial philosophy of trying to be Die Stillen im Lande.” (The quiet on the land ) That really is the essence of negating the tensions as Braun called  it and dissolving the extremes as I call it. Mennonites like to consider themselves as peace makers as well. Again dissolving opposition. Though sometimes it seems Mennonites are happy to reap the benefits of the violence of others. There is nothing morally great about that.

 

I think some people in our class found it difficult to follow Braun’s example. They wanted to oppose what they thought of as morally wrong, even if that merely sharpened the polarizations. I tend to do that too,  but it makes a difference how you oppose it. Some means of opposition result in the other cementing his or her position more tightly and indelibly. Braun’s way is to meander towards reconciliation wherever possible. He does it softly and always with gentleness some find irksome and I found encouraging.

 

I would say the best part of Braun’s classes on the upside down view of polarization as he called it, was his example of gentleness in action.  He taught by example. Usually the best way to do it.

 

I wish I could be more like that.

 

The Spy

 

The Spy is a powerful and thought-provoking Netflix limited series in which Sacha Baron Cohen is found in a serious role rather than his more common comic roles.  I loved the comedies that I watched. He plays the male lead in the series which purports to tell the true and tragic story of Eli Cohen (no relation), an astounding under deep cover Israeli Mossad agent in Syria in the 1960s.

 

Hadar Ratzon Rotem plays Cohens intense wife, Nadia, and Noah Emmerich  his morally conflicted handler, Dan Peleg. It is basically a thriller, and a good one, but it is also more than that.

This film asks some interesting and important questions about how far can a state go in asking one of its citizens to go in making sacrifices for his or her country? How big must an ask be, before it is too big? Are there limits on what a country can ask, if the work of that individual astonishingly valuable to the country?

As well there is a corollary question, when is an individual wrong in sacrificing himself and his family for the benefit of his or her country? When is it legitimate for the citizen and family to say the limit of sacrifice has been reached?  When must the country say, this is the limit and refrain from using him or her anymore because anything beyond this is intolerable?

Or are there no such limits? What can possibly be right and just?

Finally, what would it mean if there were no limits?

These are interesting and important questions handled with maturity rather than juvenile bravado unlike so many other films. Especially, action films which I sometimes think have reached their limits.

I think this series is worth a watch.

The idolatry of worshiping our own opinions

 

Will Braun said he had done some work with indigenous people in Northern Manitoba whose land would be affected greatly by hydro-electric dams being constructed. They ask you to stop the work you are doing because it is harming our first nation.  At the same time, others say we need this development for more badly needed hydro-electric power and sometimes jobs in their community.   There was a lot of tension. The good guys and bad guys are all mixed up. None of the people can be dismissed. How do you dissolve  the tension? How do you hold the tension in check?

 

Added to that, Will Braun is a journalist. In that job he has from time to time been called to interview people with whom he disagrees. How should he speak to such people?

 

One time, when he was interviewing someone about climate change who was opposed to doing anything about it, Braun realized he had never seriously considered the views of such climate deniers. Then he decided to do that. Take those contrarian views to seriously to heart.  That helped ease the tension.

 

This is an aspect of intellectual modesty. Consider that you might be wrong.  Don’t make an idol of your own opinions.

 

Will Braun had what  I thought was a very inteersting way of saying what he felt we should not do. First, we must remember the obvious that none of us is infallible. Whether you are a person of the left, the right, or the centre, there are reasonable people of goodwill who do not share your fundamental convictions. This does not mean that all opinions are equally valid or that all speakers are equally worth listening to. It certainly does not mean that there is no truth to be discovered. Nor does it mean that you are necessarily wrong. But “they” are not necessarily wrong either. So someone who has not fallen into what Braun called  “the idolatry of worshiping his or her own opinions” and loving them above truth itself will want to listen to people who see things differently in order to learn what considerations—evidence, reasons, arguments—led them to a place different from where one happens, at least for now, to find oneself.

As John Stuart Mill, my favourite philosopher on such issues said, a recognition of the possibility that we may be in error is a good reason to listen to and honestly consider—and not merely to tolerate grudgingly—points of view that we do not share, and even perspectives that we find shocking or scandalous. Intellectual modesty is also very important if one actually wants to learn from the other.

What’s more, as Mill noted, even if one happens to be right about this or that disputed matter, seriously and respectfully engaging people who disagree will deepen one’s understanding of the truth and sharpen one’s ability to defend it. That is what truth seeking is all about,

Some of us, me included, have a hard time being humble. That is not helpful.  Humility  can go a long way towards melting the extremes.

 

A Peak at the Darkness

 

Our instructor Will Braun, whom I mentioned in my most recent post, is  the editor of the Canadian Mennonite. The class I also mentioned  was an  on-line virtual class facilitated by Canadian Mennonite University.  The invitation from them  had said it would “an upside down look at polarization.”  That title intrigued me. What did it mean? What could I expect? Is there a better more fruitful way of looking at this issue?

 

A lot of people have been talking about polarization for a couple of years now, and virtually everyone says they hate it, but no one seems to be able to do anything about it. Some of us hate it but actually contribute to refinforcing it. Could we do something about that  with Will Braun’s help?  I was hoping so. I knew I could use some help.

 

First, he said, he wanted us to take a deep breath, because the issue of polarization requires us to look at our own inner lives. That requires our attention, so the first thing we need to do is slow down.

 

Braun started with a thought experiment, as he called it. He asked us to

 

“think about a person with whom we disagree with quite sharply. That person calls us up and acknowledges we have butted heads over the years and I know there is some underlying tension between us. I want to understand you better and how you got to where you are and to how you think. Can we get together to talk about this?”

 

 

This assumes of course that we would be willing to participate in such a discussion. What would motivate a person to do that? What would I think about that? How would I feel about this?

 

We will come back to this later.

 

The word “polarization” denotes two poles. As a result, we need some way to define those poles whether we like to do that or not.  For example, the poles could be left-wing or right-wing. Or conservative or liberal (or progressive). All such categories are insufficient. He said he assume most of us are left or progressive, but says he has become disenchanted with the left though that has been his team. “The camp I was once in does not feel as comfortable any more as it once did.” I would like to suggest that this is part of a common shift to the right. Not a complete shift but a widespread partial shift in that direction. Perhaps the left has gone off the rails and it has become a little too overheated or too extreme or too polarized.  Or perhaps the right is just fatigued with the issues the left keeps bringing up.

 

I think many feel this way. The most famous person I think who has said something like this was  Bill Maher. He seems to me to like the left less and less. In fact he has admitted that. He claims they have changed not him. I too come from this perspective too but perhaps am still more or less on that side.

 

What we have to do to have discussions about issues like this is that we must banish bashing. And sneering too. No mocking.  Will used an expression that he likes more than I like and that is this: “we must remember that we are all beloved of God.” I agree with the tone of this comment if not all of the specific contents of it. To discuss such issues, I would suggest we must hold our polarized views in check. If we are sliding towards hate, we have certainly gone too far. None of us are worthless. I think that sums up Braun’s view which aligns closely with my own.

 

Will is like me in that he lives in a very derisive community where most of the people I talk to are much more conservative than I am. Yet I know that most of them are good people, even though they are different from me. I don’t want to sneer at them or mock them. I want to understand them better and either move closer to their views or nudge them in my direction. As Braun said, “I don’t want to throw such people under the bus.” I don’t want to dismiss them. I won’t put them all into “a basket of deplorables” like Hillary Clinton did so disastrously. Nothing good would come of that, I am certain.

 

Some people who engage in discussion about polarization quickly assume that this will be a good opportunity to bash the other side. The bad guys, of course are wrong, for they disagree with me and I am right. I think that is a fairly normal attitude.

 

In such discussions there is often some tension. The blood pressure might go up. We will have to accept that. This is an issue about what people feel strongly about.

 

Then Braun used an expression I have trouble with. I have trouble with it because to me it does not seem that clear. He says, he wanted us always, “to tend to the heart.” He calls this a grounding point.  Braun said, “when I engage in such questions my goal is not to change minds, but to change my heart.”  Again, I have a little trouble getting this? It sounds attractive but what does it actually mean? Yet I think there is something to this notion.  I feel like if I am concentrating on that task I have a better chance of finding common ground with the other. Perhaps that might ease the tension. Frankly, I have recently experienced exactly the tension Braun mentions with good friends and I would like to ease that tension. Is it possible? Can I do it?