Robin Wall Kimmerer is a mother, scientist, professor, and member of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation. She has written a wonderful book, called Braiding Sweetgrass. She is a botanist and combines that profession with indigenous traditional knowledge she has learned from elders. She respects both branches of knowledge. We should too.
What is really special about her and her book is that she has written it with the benefit of western scientific knowledge as well as indigenous knowledge. When the two work together the results can be magnificent. Readers of her book will benefit from this dual knowledge.
In the book Kimmerer tells of a question she asked of her College Ecology students: what they could tell her about positive interactions between humans and the earth? Almost all of them could not think of any. She tried to explain that to herself and said it must be because they had seen so many negative interactions like brownfields, factory farms, suburban sprawl and a host of others. It was easy to think of negative interactions between humans and nature, but not good ones. Kimmerer described this as follows: “As the landscape becomes impoverished, so too does the scope of their vision.”
This reminded me of what Anthony Hall said in a magnificent book, The American Empire and the Fourth World where he showed there was direct line from ecocide (destruction of the earth) to genocide (destruction of first nations). Europeans, when they arrived in the New World, were quick to found their domination over not just Indigenous peoples, but nature itself. Everything was considered available to them for conquest. The Westerners rejected the ecological egalitarianism of the indigenous people they encountered who had an entirely different attitude to nature. They saw humans as part of the natural world
The people of the western world had a creation myth that told a story of Adam and Even who would have dominion over all the creatures of the earth. That dominion has proved a mixed blessing at best, as we look at a world of brownfields, pollution, and climate change.
Robin Wall Kimmerer asked how could we begin to find a path forward in this toxic relationship between nature and humans if we cannot even imagine what that path might look like. Does that mean the case is utterly hopeless? I would suggest it is impossible unless we conceive of a new attitude to nature. Nothing less will do. We need an attitude to nature similar to that of Indigenous people.