Whacky Can be Dangerous

 

A lot of people—me included—have been giggling about the whacky claims made by Donald Trump against immigrants. Why do conservatives believ such crazy stuff?

 

The claims were whacky. They deserved our ridicule. But they can also be dangerous.

As political commentator Ana Navarro said, passionately, on CNN,

 

“This thing that Donald Trump said about immigrants eating cats and dogs came out of left field and you thought he was completely absolutely insane. If Joe Biden had said the same thing he would have been pulled off the stage and sent immediately to a loony bin, but because Donald Trump gets away with being Donald Trump, and saying crazy things. What’s happening with Donald Trump, as Kamala Harris said, he always goes to an old tired playbook. He always tries to go against immigrants. He tries to cause fear. He tries to build that so folks vote out of fear. Last week it was about Venezuelan gangs taking over Aurora Colorado. The official of that city said that story was false. This week it is a completely made-up story about somebody eating a cat and it turning into a Haitian immigrant. It may be funny to some people. A lot of people have made funny memes. But it’s also incredibly racist and incredibly dangerous. Because I remember when a whack job triggered by things that were said against Latinos, took a gun and hunted down Latinos in an El Paso Walmart. And I remember when a whack job triggered by conspiracy theories  went to the Comet Pizza Parlour in Washington D.C. and sex ring that the Clinton’s were supposedly running there showed up there with a gun. So, its crazy. It may be funny. It may lead to a lot of memes but it’s also racist and dangerous and it is shameful that it continues to be amplified by people like Donald Trump his followers and his vice-presidential candidate.”

 

Once again Donald Trump is an instrument of ignorance and hatred. This is a deadly and combustible mixture that we must expunge from our societies. People, like me, ask where all the hatred and violence in America come from. Some of us blame guns. Others blame a lack of religion or a lack of morality. Some of us blame the other side. There is plenty of blame that can we spread around like shit from a honey wagon, but without a doubt, political leaders like Donald Trump and his cohorts, deserve a significant portion of the blame. Their actions against vulnerable immigrants are despicable and disgraceful. They really are not funny. They are dangerous.

 

Lies have Consequences

 

There are rational claims made against allowing the current immigration system in the US to continue.  Not all objections are racist or bigoted.  For example, as an immigration lawyer said the day after the election on CNN,  in some small towns in America,  they are overwhelmed by thousands of immigrants who have been flown in to make “asylum” claims that amount really to desires to pursue the American dream. These people are not real asylum seekers at all and they are jumping the queue  when there are already millions of legitimate claims for asylum in America that should have their case heard before these.

 

This could have been debated in the presidential debate. Instead, Trump claimed immigrants are eating cats and dogs without evidence to back up his claims. He does this to rile up his base.  Fox News does the same thing. Trump does not care about evidence, or even truth. Neither does Fox News. Trump just wants to make his anti-immigrant statements as pumped up as possible. He wants to throw raw meat to his base. He does not want a rational debate. Rational debate is being obfuscated by Trump’s electioneering and “firehose of lies.’

As Laura Coates said on CNN, “such false claims lead to fear mongering and ‘otherism’ and someone purportedly eating pets.” Such lies trigger hate and make rational debate and discussion impossible. That is exactly what Trump wants to do.  The last thing he wants is to have a rational debate since he knows in a rational debate his arguments crumble like stale cookies on a hot September night.

Such lying can have serious consequences. As Chuck Rocha a political commentator said on CNN the day after the presidential debate, “This is dangerous by the way when you say this in front of 68 million people on TV, for such lies can trigger crazy people to do what they did in El Paso, and take a gun to a Walmart.”

We must demand more from our political candidates. We must not let them get away with such nonsense.

 

 

A Firehose of Lies

 

We live in the age of lies. Lies are so pervasive in our society that we rarely find them remarkable.

On September 10, 2024 Vice-President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump engaged in a televised 90 minute debate broadcast on the  ABC television network.  The debate was spectacular in many ways. One was in the number of lies that were told by one of the candidates. Guess which one?

CNN’s senior reporter Daniel Dale   who reported on CNN immediately after the debate concluded said this:

“what stood out tonight was that this was a staggeringly dishonest debate performance by from former president Trump—just lie after lie after lie on subject after subject. By my preliminary count Trump made at least 33 false claims. By contrast again by a preliminary count, vice-president Kamala Harris made at least 1 false claim, though she added at least a few more misleading claims and a few more that lacked key context. I think that most Americans say ‘well all politicians lie, but no major political presidential candidate before Donald Trump has lied with this sort of frequency.  A remarkably large chunk of what he said tonight was just not true. And this wasn’t like little exaggeration or political spin. A lot of his false claims were untethered to reality. Like on abortion, saying “every Democrat wanted Roe v. Wade overturned” when actually more than 80% of Democrats supported Roe v. Wade. On crime, saying it was “through the roof” when actually it has come sharply down since 2023. It’s now lower than it was when Trump left office. On health care, saying he’s the one who saved Obama care, the law that he repeatedly tried to overturn. On Kamala Harris herself, saying that a Howard University grad, a black law students’ association president, had claimed that she wasn’t black at one point. Frankly, I don’t have enough time here to run through each false Trump claim. I urge people to go to our CNN website or our app to read our team’s detailed fact checks on this and a whole bunch more.”

 

CNN a year and half ago during a televised Town Hall broadcast by the same CNN news channel, had referred in a headline to Donald Trump saying he was spewing out “a firehose of lies.” That sums it up pretty well.  Oliver Darcy said it this way:

 

It’s hard to see how America was served by the spectacle of lies that aired on CNN Wednesday evening.

Kaitlan Collins is as tough and knowledgable of an interviewer as they come. She fact-checked Trump throughout the 70-minute town hall. Over and over and over again, she told him that the election was not stolen. That it was not rigged. That there was no evidence for the lies he was disseminating on stage.

“The election was not rigged, Mr. President,” Collins told Trump at one point during the event. “You cannot keep saying that all night long.”

Yet, he did. Trump frequently ignored or spoke over Collins throughout the evening as he unleashed a firehose of disinformation upon the country, which a sizable swath of the GOP continues to believe. A professional lie machine, Trump fired off falsehoods at a rapid clip while using his bluster to overwhelm Collins, stealing command of the stage at some points of the town hall.

Trump lied about the 2020 election. He took no responsibility for the January 6 insurrection that those very lies incited. And he mocked E. Jean Carroll’s allegations of sexual assault, which a jury found him liable for on Tuesday.”

This debate was another such night in front of millions of American television viewers seeing him disgorge lie after lie apparently without notice or shame or regret. Trump was indeed “A professional lie machine,” as Darcy said.

Dale said instead of trying to cover all those lies live on TV he would focus on one “egregious false claim.” This was the one about migrants supposedly eating people’s pets.

This is what he said,

In Springfield they’re eating the dogs. The people that came in. They’re eating the cats. They’re eating the pets—eating the pets—of the people that live there.”

 

This was a crazy conspiracy theory that reminded me a lot of another crazy conspiracy theory spread a year or so ago about young people in schools transitioning to cats and demanding kitty litter in schools. I cannot blame Kamala Harris for laughing during the former president’s presentation of these absurd claims. Why does the MAGA crowd believe so much crazy stuff? As Dale said,

 

This is not only false, I think it is fair to call this odious. For people who have not been online the last couple of days, this claim about Haitian migrants in Springfield Ohio eating people’s pets originated with a Facebook post that attributed the claim to a “neighbour’s friend’s daughter.” A third hand broken telephone kind of thing. The city of Springfield and the Springfield police  say there are no credible reports of this happening. And even J.D. Vance the vice-presidential candidate who himself had promoted these claims, acknowledged this morning that the “rumors” might prove out to be false though he still encouraged people to spread these cat memes. Trump himself added dogs ot the equation. They had not even been part of these viral nonsense rumours before.

 

CNN also looked at the one false claim made by Harris during the debate. She said, “Let’s talk about what Donald Trump left us. Donald Trump left us the worst unemployment since       the Great Depression. And what we have done is clean up Donald Trump’s mess.”

 

As Dale analyzed,

“So, the Biden Harris administration was not actually left the worst unemployment. They were left a 6.4% unemployment in January 2021. That was certainly elevated by recent standards. It was pretty high, but it was significantly down from the 14.8% a level it reached in early in the pandemic. So it was already improving at the time that Biden-Harris administration took office and that 14.8% was the highest since the Great Recession. So in the last 20 years not going back decades further.

 

Harris’s lie was a pipsqueak compared to Trump’s big fat lies!

 

Private Super Powers

 

Libraries are under attack around the world. This includes libraries in the Bible Belt where evangelicals want to control what people can read according to their own agenda.

Libraries are also attacked by a thousand budget cuts, right-wing extremists who abhor the freedom to know, and in some places, like Bosnia Herzegovina  by actual bombs.

According to Richard Ovenden in his lecture at the Toronto Public Library,

“We are going through a profound shift in the way that knowledge is created, shared and stored at the moment. As a result, public knowledge is increasingly in the hands of major technologies, or what the Oxford historian, Timothy Garton Ash , has called “private super powers.”

 

 

That really is an appropriate phrase for an age in which private individuals are taking over the world of so much that used to be solely within the public domain, including space travel, policing, armed forces, universities, hospitals, and so much else. The private domain is expanding with electric speed, while the public realm, after decades of neo-liberal ideological dominance is shrinking to the size of a modest bath tub like the wealthy had hoped.  Think about it—recently a private army marched on Moscow and the leader Putin cringed and made a deal with Prigozhin. That would have been unimaginable a mere 5 years ago.  Now people shrug at the insolence. What else is new, or as Bob Dylan said, “what else can you show me?”

Ovenden also mentioned how archives have changed in the modern age of emails, Twitter (now X), Tik Tok, and other new social media.  Who ever thought presidents of the richest most powerful country in the world would communicate directly to his fevered followers on Twitter or Truth Social at 3 a.m. clearly without the benefit of any curation or communications advice? In fact, such communications are not just made without such advice, but probably against such advice!

We have also seen a former president of the US, Donald Trump, housing classified materials in the washrooms of his private club and then bragging about it to his swooning cronies. Life doesn’t get much crazier than this. Is that how Trump was creating his presidential library in the age of social media and fake news?

The examples of President Trump and President Biden and Vice-President Pence each moving state documents to their private homes highlights the problems of mixing up private and public archives so casually. How can such a society carry on? Are these each merely one more example of the decline of modern democracies?

Another example was provided by Ovenden:

“The current investigation by the British House of Commons into former Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s administration during the COVID-19 crisis, focusing on messages exchanged by senior figures, highlights the critical importance of these records for the health of our democracy. They used encrypted messaging systems like WhatsApp, and Telegram to evade the normal routine of keeping records in their department, evading the Freedom of Information regimes, and long-term archiving.”

 

To quote Dylan again, ‘The Times they are a-changing.”  And they will never be the same again and we had better make sure we protect our freedom to read from challenges posed by a wide variety of sources. We must do this at our peril.

An attack on civilization and knowledge

 

An attack on a library is an attack on civilization.

On August 25 1991 the library in Bosnia’s capital city of Sarajevo was shelled by the Serbian forces. No other buildings were attacked that day. Just their magnificent library. It was a deliberate barbarian attack on Bosnian civilization by brutes from Serbia. Serb snipers then picked off people who went to try to save the books in the building. One of them was killed. Few rare books were saved. It was too dangerous. Of course, the Serbian attacked people too.  It was the greatest assault in Europe since the Second World War.

According to Richard Ovenden, “the library was a target because it was both the symbol of a multi-cultural community that Bosnia and Herzegovina had managed to preserve and it contained the written culture and history of Muslims, Christians, and Jews all living together.” This really shows that the attack was an attack on civilization and knowledge. That is why I refer to the Serbs engaged in that attack as “brutes.”  It is a hard word, but I would suggest, not inappropriate in such circumstances.

Such an attack shows how the aggressors thought the Bosnians were not civilized, revealing, as such attacks inevitably do, that it is the aggressor who is uncivilized.

According to Ovenden,

“On the evening of August 25, 1992, shells began to rain down on a building in Bosnia’s capital city of Sarajevo. The shells were incendiaries, designed to raise fire rapidly on impact, especially when surrounded by combustible material. The building they hit was the National and University Library of Bosnia and Herzegovina. No other buildings were fired on this day — the library was the sole target for the shells.”

 

The National Library in Sarajevo reopened on May 9, 2014 — 22 years after the landmark building was destroyed during the Bosnian war, along with its nearly two million books and manuscripts.

Civilization and knowledge rose again from the ashes of Sarajevo.

 

Migration

 

The ruby-throated hummingbirds, which we saw at the English Country Garden, were likely preparing for it migration. In fact, we did not see the red throats. That is not unusual. The red is only visible when the light is just right. Added to that, only the males have the gorgeous red throats and I have heard that males start migration before the females. They might be out of the province all ready.  They don’t require health insurance. When conditions are right, they take off. Can anyone blame them?

 

Some of the ruby-throated hummingbirds migrate over the Gulf of Mexico enroute to South America. As result, they will load up seriously on nutrients before their long flight. During this process, that takes about 2 weeks, the hummingbird will double its body weight.  Across the Gulf of Mexico on the way to South America they are not able to stop. Stopping means death.

 

There basically are very few islands in the Gulf. As a result, they usually embark on a 500-mile non-stop flight that takes about 20 hours and during this time the bird loses 70% of its body weight in less than a day!

 

The hummers I saw at Assiniboine Park were no doubt getting ready to migrate down south. Their migrations are so astonishing that many continue to think that they hitch rides on the bodies of geese. Personally, I think that is a conspiracy theory. Others claim they ride on cruise ships.

 

After all, how could such a tiny bird fly non-stop across the Gulf of Mexico?  Yet they do it; somehow, as the shoe company says, they “just do it”. Some of them actually follow the coast, taking a longer but safer route. Across the Gulf if the bird encounters a head wind it can die. Headwinds can be deadly. No one said the life of a hummingbird is easy? They also don’t fly in formation to make it easier, as geese do. They migrate alone. That is one lonely and tough flight. It makes even an Air Canada flights look good.

 

Some of them actually follow the coast, taking a longer but safer route. Across the Gulf if the bird encounters a head wind it can die. Who said the Life of a hummingbird is easy? They don’t fly in formation to make it easier. They migrate alone.

 

For many reasons, humans are enamored of hummingbirds.  Who could blame us? As Charles Bowden who frequently wrote for Arizona Highways magazine,  explained,

 

We are all seduced by hummingbirds, by the flash of color, the sudden iridescence, the rapid movement, the hovering, and the fact that something so small will fly right up to our face. In a world where so much of the wild flees at our approach, hummingbirds seem to promise redemption, whatever the real reason for their behavior.

 

According to Susan Wethington, “Hummingbirds are one of the few animals people connect with immediately, and every culture with hummingbirds has a positive connection. I think hummingbirds provide an opportunity to engage people in nature and open eyes to the natural world. And quite frankly, if we can’t save hummingbirds, what group of animals can we save?” ]

 

Bowden was right when he said, “If you want to see the only future worth being part of, you join the world of hummingbirds.” [3] It really does make sense to “protect the joy.” Personally, I don’t want to be a part of a world without hummingbirds.  How about you?

 

 

Some hummingbirds don’t migrate.  The Anna’s hummingbirds live year round in Arizona. Who could blame them for staying? Why do the others leave? Others like the Ruby-throated and Rufous-sided hummingbird migrate amazing distances. Before migrating, hummingbirds have to stock up on a lot of calories. They become “eating machines,” according to Krebbs. They need fat, fat, and more fat to cross the Gulf of Mexico for example, as some ruby-throats traverse that huge bay, it takes about 2 grams of fat for a hummingbird to travel 600 miles. Remember, hummingbirds don’t weigh much more than 2 grams. I gram is equal to 9 calories. They burn from .69 to .74 calories per hour.  About 2 grams of fat are needed to cross the Gulf of Mexico. That is why hummingbirds have to nearly double their weight before they embark on this incredible flight.  That means hummingbirds consume a piddly 18 calories to cross the Gulf of Mexico.

 

The ruby-throated hummingbird, which is the most common hummingbird in Manitoba, and the only one I have seen here, is an amazing migrant. It spends its winters in South America and therefore the poor ruby-throated hummingbird has to make an epic journey twice each year. This is the longest migration of any bird in comparison to the size of the bird (except see Rufous). The tiny bird must fly a mighty marathon to cross the Gulf of Mexico in a steady flight of 18 hours across 500 miles of open water. All of this is done without stopping. Stopping would be fatal. So it cannot drink or feed while it crosses the Gulf.

The long and short of it—especially short—is that hummingbirds are amazing creatures.

Magicians in the Air

 

 

Hummingbirds can fly at speeds of up to 50mph. Not bad for such a tiny bird!  But that is far from their most remarkable achievements.   The flying abilities of hummingbirds allow them to produce dazzling speeds. They need that speed in order not just to find flowers, but get at the nectar before their competitors, other hummingbirds, interfere with them. They also like to avoid photographers. Then they need to fly and react fast.

The flight of the hummingbird is one of the marvels of the natural world. Hummingbirds are able to rotate their wings at the shoulder because of their modified wing bones.

A couple of years ago, I watched a wonderful TV show, Magic in the Air. In it Professor Doug Aufschuler, interviewed on the show called them “some of the most elite athletes of the animal world.”  That is surely no exaggeration. They can fly, not just backwards, but in a figure 8 pattern. They can also  fly briefly fly upside down.

Hummingbirds need a lot of fuel each day because “their metabolism is stuck in overdrive,” as the television show aptly put it. Even at “rest” the hummingbird’s heart beats up to 600 times per minute or 10 times per second!  What kind of a “rest” is that? When it is active that heart can beat twice that—i.e. 1,200 times per minute or 20 times per second!  Their hearts beat at about 10 times that of an average human.

No wonder they need such large hearts. That is why the heart of the hummingbird accounts for nearly 1/3 of the bird’s weight.

The Anna’s hummingbird which we saw often in Arizona, has a spectacular mating display which I have seen. The male dives at the females and chirps at amazing speeds. It has been thought to dive at an incredible 10 G’s, similar to the force at which jet pilots black out.

 Hummingbirds are astonishing birds. I watched a PBS show on Nature called “Super Hummingbirds.”  That is an appropriate title. It was fascinating because Hummingbirds are fascinating.

As they said on that show, “Nothing in the world is a like a hummingbird. Their abilities border on the magical. They fly with such speed they seem to alter time.”  Or how about this one, “Hummingbirds seem to spring from the imagination. They have abilities other birds don’t have. Time seems to bend for them.”

Their wings also beat at astonishing rates. The wings beat at more than 70 times per second! Even high-speed cameras blur those wings.

 The high-definition cinematography used in that in the show was also outstanding. They had some amazing shots of a hummingbird coming right into a flower. How is that possible? Obviously, they had put a tiny camera inside a flower! Humans are almost as amazing as hummingbirds!

Even though hummingbirds fly so fast it often seems like one could not be sure if one saw a hummingbird or not. They are like tiny phantoms. Yet, “Hummingbirds are made to be seen. They catch the light.  These sunlit gems evoke such wonder, we struggle to describe them.”

 These really are astonishing birds. Among the most fascinating in the endlessly fascinating world of birds. As the television show said, “hummingbirds are more than just beautiful, they are brilliant.” I could not have said it better myself

“Astounding” seems like much too mild a word.

 

Mother Nature was not cooperating

 

When I went to the English Country Garden to try my best to photograph the hummingbirds  all of my problems were exasperated by the incredible winds. If the hummingbird landed on a branch in the sun, as it did from time to time, it was only for a brief moment. And then, as often as not, the wind moved the branch a great distance and the bird somehow managed to hang on for dear light. Of course, by then, the camera lens was no longer pointed at the bird, but that darned tree again.

 

This was the most amazing race of technologies.  The Bird technology  was holding its own however. It would alight on a branch or hover in front of a flower for just the briefest moment before moving on. I was profoundly challenged to keep up. The John Neufeld technology was not working so great. I was in the real  amazing race. And most I was losing.

 

Added to that, however, the birds had one flaw which made it almost impossible to grab an image in focus.  They would constantly be chasing each other. These tiny hummingbirds are amazingly territorial. Even though there was an abundance of nectar—the nectar of the Gods, yet each bird would try to chase away each competitor. That just  showed they have evolved. Don’t let any other bird get your nectar!  Even if it means they were wasting an in incredible amount of time in which they could be fuelling up, they  were instead chasing the competition away. This was insanity.

 

This was insane.  Each bird in the garden could easily find plenty of flowers for itself. Hummingbirds are the tiniest birds in the western hemisphere.  A baby hummingbird is about as heavy as a post-it note! As soon as they can fly, they are constantly on the move.  They stop for very short and infrequent rest stops. Like this bird posing for me in the sun. Mocking me and my feeble efforts.